On Mar 5, 8:45 am, mobsiab <***@gmail.com> wrote:
> On Mar 5, 7:14 am, Yaj Tshaj Koob <***@yahoo.com> wrote:
>
>
>
>
>
> > On Mar 4, 8:28 pm, Victor <***@hotmail.com> wrote:
>
> > > On Mar 5, 12:12 pm, TUB <***@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> > > > See this old letter from Mr. Chimeng Yang (Dr. Paoze Thos's
> > > > associate).
>
> > > >http://mong.ws/email_response.htm
>
> > > Dear Tub,
>
> > > I agree with what was written in Chimeng Yang's letter. I went to
> > > China in 98. I from Kunming, I traveled to Kuj Cawm, Huj khaw,Maum
> > > Kuas , Paj Tawg, Mooj Ntxw. Txhua-txhua qhov chaw kuv mus, kuv tsis
> > > ntsib ib tug Hmoob hais lus Hmoob hlo li. Kuv ntsib txhua tus Hmoob
> > > hais lus Moob xwb. Kuv nug lawv, lawv qee leej kuj hais tias lawv yog
> > > Hmoob Dawb. Qee leej kuj hais tias lawv yog Moob Lees. Tabsis txawm
> > > Hmoob Dawb thiab Moob Lees los yeej hais lus tib lub suab Moob Lees
> > > xwb. Thov qab nug lawv tas lawm es yus mam ua tib zoo mloog ces yus
> > > tiaj mam paub qee lo hais tias yog lus Hmoob Dawb xwb. Ib yam li tus
> > > Hmoob Dawb yuav hais tias "txhuv" hos tus Moob Lees yuav hais tias
> > > "ntsab". Yog li, kuv txawm yog Hmoob Dawb los kuv yeej conclude li
> > > Chimeng Yang hais thiab hais tias Moob Lees coob dua Hmoob Dawb.
>
> > > Vim lub sij hawm Vaj Pov ua rog, Vaj Pov yog Hmoob Dawb ces txhua leej
> > > cia li hais tus thawj hom lus lawm xwb. Yog yuav debate tiag-tiag hais
> > > tias leej twg yog sub-group ntawm leej twg ces tej zaum kuv yuav
> > > conclude hais tias Hmoob Dawb yog sub-group ntawm Moob Lees nyob ntiaj
> > > teb no.
>
> > > Raws li kuv assess, lub suab lus Hmoob Dawb nrov tawv dua lub suab lus
> > > Moob Lees. Txawm tus tib neeg kiag los kuv pom hais tias Hmoob Dawb
> > > coj ceev dua Moob Lees. Tsis tas li no xwb, kuv xav hais tias cov
> > > Hmoob nyob Nplog Teb feem coob yog cov tub rog uas noj tsis tau nyob
> > > tsis tau Suav Teb es pus poj niam me nyuam khiav mus rau Xov Tshoj
> > > xwb. Yog li, kuv kuj muaj peev xwm conclude tau hais tias lus Hmoob
> > > Dawb yog siv rau fab tub rog. Lus Moob Lees yog siv rau fab pej xeem
> > > (los yog fab nom tswv kav pej xeem).
>
> > > Yog li, Hmoob Dawb thiab Moob Lees sib separate tsis tau. Kuv support
> > > Chimeng Yang qhov conclusion hais tias " SEPARATE WE VANISH; TOGETHER
> > > WE SURVIVE." Peb tsis tsim nyog yuav muab Hmoob Dawb/Moob Lees los ua
> > > issue rau peb sib txiav caj dab kom tu noob. Nplog hais tias "serk leo
> > > Meo dap" xwb ces twb txaus peb lawm. Peb tsis tas ua kom qhov no tshwm
> > > sim tiag-tiag li niaj hnub no.
>
> > > Victor
>
> > Nyob zoo tus kwv Victor,
>
> > Kuv nyeem koj cov lus yeej yog li koj hais lawm, yog muab xyuas meej
> > meej ces Hmoob tsis tsim nyog yuav ub hais no lawm, tas nrho cov tub
> > kawm txawj tsis ntse coob, peb twb paub tias ib tug tub txawj nws twb
> > kho tsis tau ib rooj nyuag plaub hauv kwv tij, yuav ua cas kho tau
> > Hmoob, peb txhob xav tias tsuav yog kawv ntawv siab lawm ces txawm siv
> > tau no, qhov kev kawm ntawv ces yog leej twg rau siab kawm ces txawm
> > tau Dr. xwb, tus neeg ntse kawm tau ntawv ntse, tus ruam zog kuj kawm
> > tau ntawv ruam thiab, muaj ntau tus kawm ntawv siab twb los hais lus
> > rau public twb tsis muaj neeg xav mloog, twb tsis piv tej tus neeg
> > tsis muaj kev kawm.
>
> > Thiab kuv kuj pom li Chimeng Yang hais thiab, kuj siv tau lawm thiab,
> > peb Hmoob tsis muaj ob peb pawg Hmoob es nyias tshwm sim nyias los ib
> > qho los, peb Hmoob tsis yog ncau los ntawm ntiaj teb, los yog hlav los
> > ntawm ntiaj nrog, peb Hmoob yog lub ntuj tsim ib yam li luag txhua
> > haiv thiab.
>
> > Muaj ntau tus hais hauv no mas zoo li Hmoob muaj ob hom Hmoob / Moob
> > li ntawd tab sis Hmoob Moob yog lub suab xwb hais tawm los lus xwb,
> > kuv pom Mobsiab tseem sau tias muab ib pab ua cov coob muab ib pab ua
> > cov tsawg tsawg li ntawd, peb tsis yog cov neeg uas nyias hais muaj
> > nyias lus es yuav muab hu tau ua majority los sis hu ua manority li
> > ntawd tau, peb txhua tus nyaj yuav paub txog lub suab yog dab tsis
> > lawm thiab los tsis paub, yog paub tias kev hais lus yog lub suab
> > txawv qee los lus, thiab peb twb tsis tau muab coj los tshawb fawb
> > hais tais tej lus tsis sib thooj ntawd tej zaum yog txuam lwm hom neeg
> > uas txawv tus Hmoob li cov lus rau hauv Hmoob tsev neeg lawm.
>
> > Piv txawv lus Hmoob dawb hu tias "kab tsib" kab tsib yog lus suav
> > lawm, lus Hmoob yog "quav ntsuas" quav ntsuas thiaj yog lus Hmoob.
> > Moob Leeg hu tias "xaab cum" xaab cum yog lus suav lawm, lus Hmoob yog
> > "lub kos" nej muab ob qho no coj los xyuas xwb nej yeej paub zoo tias
> > Hmoob txuam lwm yam lus ntau heev lawm ces Hmoob / Moob thiaj txawm
> > cia li tsis sib txheeb lawm.
>
> > Cwjmem koj sau tau ib cov lus yog lus heev thiab meej lawm tiag vim
> > muaj cov Dov Taws coob xwb cov tau Dr. ces twb tsis muaj pes tsawg
> > leej, hais lus li cov Dov taws hais xwb ces Hmoob tseem yuav tawg ua
> > ntau tshaj nov ntxiv. Ua ca los kuv ntseeg tias yuav muaj ib tug txawj
> > thiab ntse tiag tiag los kho tau Hmoob xwb xwb tab sis tsis yog cov
> > Dov taws ntawd kho. Cov Dov taws ntawd tsua txawj tus nyuag ntawv xwb
> > yuav kho tsis tau Hmoob.
>
> > Hais txog lub suab tias Hmoob / Moob no muaj coob leej mus suav teb
> > twb paub tsis txog tias muaj pes tsawg hom hais lus tawm lub suab tias
> > Hmoob, thiab ho muaj pes tsawg hom hais tawm lub suab tias Moob no.
> > Kuv twb muab qhia rau peb ntau zaug lawm sawv daws yeej tsis nkag siab
> > li nyias tsuas qhuas nyias luj txw ua tau xwb.
>
> > Cov uas hais lus tawm lub suab tias "Hmoob" no mas muaj xws li Hmoob
> > dawb, Hmoob Leeg, Hmoob Ntsuab, Hmoob Peg, Hmoob pua, Hmoob Xauv,
> > Hmoob Yob sua, thiab lwm hom uas hais lus peb tsis tsha paub lawv cov
> > lus zoo ntawd los tseem hu los lus tias Hmoob no ua "Hmoob thiab". Cov
> > uas ho hais lus lub suab tawm tias "Moob" no tsuas muaj tib pab thiaj
> > hais tawm lub suab tias Moob no xwb, pab no yog hu ua Moob Sib no peb
> > Hmoob leej twg sau ntawv yog sau tus tsiaj ntawv tawm lub suab tias
> > Moob no ces nej yog Moob Sib lawm nej tsis yog Hmoob leeg, leej twg
> > tsis ntseeg los thov sawv daws mus kawm ntxiv kom paub hmoob zoo zoo
> > tso mam los sib cam, sib kho.
>
> > Haam Choj Txoov tuam thawj coj Hmoob nyob suav teb tau hais ib cov lus
> > txaus Hmoob Meskas tus siab yog txawj xav, Haam Choj Txoov hais li no,
> > nws hais tias Hmoob nyob suav teb lawv coob heev lawv tseem koom tau
> > los hnav ib lub ris ua ke, Hmoob meskas tsawg heev twb koom tsis tau
> > ib lub ris hnav nws hais li, thiab Hmoob asmeskas mas khav theeb heev
> > ua tsis tau daab tsis, thaum xub thawj lawv kuj cia siab rau Hmoob
> > asmeskas, tab sis lawv muab ntsia mus ntsia los Hmoob meskas thiab cov
> > kiav rau xov tshoj txawm yog cov uas rhuav Hmoob ntag.
>
> > Tus yuav los coj Hmoob tsis yog cov hais lus li pab uas peb tseem tab
> > tom hais no, kuv ntsia mas lam kawm tau lub nyuag npe xwb twb tsis
> > niam muaj txuj ci ib nyuag qhov li, tsuas hais qhov uas yuav muab cais
> > nyias nyob nyias xwb ces yog ruam tshaj nov tsis muaj lawm os cov Dov
> > taws Moob /Hmoob ai!!!. Ntxiv ib los rau tus kwv Cwjmem koj pom txog
> > txoj kev kuv pom thiaj kuv txhawb koj lub zog uas zoo, yuav los nrog
> > kho Moob /Hmoob.
>
> > YTK
>
> Tus kwvtij YTK, koj yog ib tus kuv respect tias koj paub lus hmoob
> ntau thiab keeb kwm hmoob zoo. Kuv xav mas koj sau tias koj pomzoo
> lis Chimeng thiab Victor nkawd hais thiab pom hais tia kuv yog tus
> hais cov coob ua majority ,cov tsawg yog minority. Kuv xav, tej zaum
> koj yuam kev lawm koj tsis support kawd , koj againt nkawd.Koj yuav
> tau rov qab ua twbzoo nyeem:1- Victor cov lus ntawd qhov subgroup saib
> nws hais li cas, 2- Tub cov lus hais rau kuv( qhov tseem ceeb yog
> yuav siv lub npe twg Hmoob los moob) yog siv ob lub ces yog THAU HAIV
> " lo lus no raws kuv totaub mas txhais tias tshem haiv ua kom puas,
> los yos tsis sibhaum,sibtxeeb..." 3- koj hais tias kabtsib lus hmoob
> yog quav ntsuas ,ua quav ntsuas ne koj hov hu li cas? 4- Koj muab cov
> Drs tso rau qhov qis (put them down) koj yuav muab dabtsi coj los ua
> tus ncej tas ( lus nplog hais tias Lat. base on what ?) hais tias tus
> neeg ntawd paub tab ,muaj kev txawj ntse. Nyob mekas no,kuv paub mas
> luag tsuas siv daim diploma thiab degree coj los ua reference. Ua
> tsaug ntau kawm tau ntau yam los ntawm koj.- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -
Nyob zoo tus kwv Mobsiab,
Kuv thov txim ntau ntau nawb, ntawm qhov koj los lus majority tsis yog
koj hais, yog koj hais raws lawv lus xwb, tus kwv Mobsiab zoo yog koj
hais rov qab rau kuv paub, luag hais tias nkauj txawg yuav yuam ib
rauv, tub txawg yuav yuam ib hneev, qhov 1. koj hais tias los lus uas
Victor hais tias "sub-group ntawd mas tsis yog lus Hmoob kuv tsuas
nkag siab hais tias pawg ua qab, los sis hais tias pab rhawv lub npe
ua tom qab li ntawd" qhov 2. neb tham tias yog siv ob lub npe ces yog
thau haiv li ntawd, kuv xav mas yog Hmoob muaj teb chaws, peb yuav
muab hu hais li no, Hmoob yog lub teb chaws ces Moob yog tsav neeg los
sis haiv neeg, yog tias Moob yog lub teb chaws ces Hmoob yog haiv neeg
xwb peb tsis muab cais ua ob pab. ib lub npe yog lub teb chaws, ib lub
npe yog cov neeg / haiv neeg, "piv txwv li America yog lub teb chaws,
American yog cov neeg los yog haiv neeg li no". Qhov 3. koj nug hais
tias kab tsib yog quav ntsuas lawm no, quav ntsuas ho hu li cas, tus
quav ntsuas Hmoob hu ua "ntsuas pias los yog ntsuas no xwb". Qhov 4.
koj hais tias kuv muab cov Dr. saib qis heev lawm, yog yuav muab saib
raws li lawv 3-4 tus uas tuaj sau ntawv rau sawv daws pom no xwb ces
yeej yog li kuv hais lawm thiab, kuv muab ntsias thiab research tas
nrho ntiaj teb tib neeg cov uas sawv los ua nom ua tswv kav teb chaws
puav leej yog cov uas kawm ntawv tsis siab pes tsawg los ua tus thawj
coj ntau xwb, cov uas tau Dr. los ua thawj coj tsis muaj pes tsawg
tus, cov Dr. ces thaum twg cov pej xeem thiab cov uas kawm ntawv tsis
siab pes tsawg ua tau teb chaws los sis teeb tsa tau tej kev coj kav
teb chaws ces mam li mus txheeb hu seb cov Dr. leej twg yog hom txuj
ci dab tsib ces li coj nruab rau txoj num ntawd xwb, vim tub txawj
muaj ntau hom, nyias tsua ua tau nyias hom xwb, nws ua tsis tau tshaj
qhov ua nws txawj.
Peb Hmoob tsis paub peb lub npe Dr. lawm xwb ces peb xav tias ntshe
heev hwv lawm no, tab sis twb mus tsis txog qhov twg, nws tsuas pab
tau nws tsev neeg nkaus, cia cov Dr. los tawm tswv yim ces nyias khav
nyias ntse xwb, yim ua yim tawg loj, yim kho yim tawg dav, vim nws
tsis paub Hmoob keeb kwm zoo, nej twb pom Dr. Ly Yia nws twb yog tus
uas hais tias nim kawm Hmoob tej kev lis kev cai thiab no uas cas
nyuam qhuav hais tau nyuag nyob zoo li ntawd xwb, twb tsis haum Hmoob,
tus uas yuav los kho hais tau Hmoob tus ntawd hais qoov sua tas nrho
Hmoob thoob qab ntuj tus uas hais lus yus paub thiab tsis paub tas nro
coj los ua ke mas thiaj yog tus yuav los kho Hmoob, kuv xav tias Dr.
coc feem coob nyias tsuas kav tau nyias tus poj niam xwb, muaj ntau
tus Dr. twb kav tsis tau nws tsev neeg, tseem muaj poj nrauj yawg
nrauj Dr. coob tus, tsis tas yuav los sau sau ntawv hais txog Hmoob
lawm, nej cov Dr. tawb quav mas tsw tshaj paws ua rau Hmoob thoob
ntiaj teb tau kev txaj qhov muag kawg nkau rau lug lwm tsav neeg, rau
qhov nej cov Dr. txawj ntawv English heev nej sau ua lus English kom
neeg ntiaj teb paub tias nej mas ntse kawg, tab sis nej rab hneev mas
tua xu deb heev ntawm lub hom phiaj uas cov pej xeem Hmoob xav ua xav
kho lawm. Tiag tiag mas cov Dov taws yuav tau los thov kev zam txim
nawb rau cov me nyuam Hmoob nrsuag nos.
YTK